What is the best pizza in Birmingham: Open now?
The answer
The best pizza in Birmingham, MI open now includes Grano PizzAiolo, New York Pizza Pie Birmingham, and Brooklyn Pizza and Bar. Grano PizzAiolo is the top pick for quality ingredients and meticulous preparation with a 4.7 rating. New York Pizza Pie Birmingham is favored for New York style pizza and great crust and sauce with a 4.3 rating. Brooklyn Pizza and Bar is the closest option, known for New York style pizza but with mixed reviews on flavor and price.
Sponsored
Ranked · how we rank
- 1
4.7 from 218 Google reviews, 0.6 mi away
- Pizza is superb with high quality ingredients and meticulous preparation
“Owners and staff are great, pizza is superb.”
- 2
4.7 from 383 Google reviews, 10.4 mi away
- 4.7★ from 383 reviews · 10.4 mi
- 3
4.6 from 3,973 Google reviews, 11.4 mi away
- 4.6★ from 3,973 reviews · open till 9 PM · 11.4 mi
- 4
4.3 from 148 Google reviews, 0.5 mi away
- Popular menu items include 'The New Yorker' pizza and Cheesy Bread
“Our favorite pizza place for New York Style pizza!”
- 5
0.4 mi away, 4.3 from 965 Google reviews
- 4.3★ from 965 reviews · open till 10 PM · 0.4 mi
“Definitely NY style pizza and NY city style prices!”
Map
Sources · updated October 5, 2026
Sponsored
Ask a follow-up
Next: Pizza open late in Birmingham: Open
Answered from the places on this page.
Related questions
- What are the hours for Grano PizzAiolo in Birmingham: Open now?
- Does Grant's Pizza House offer delivery in Birmingham: Open?
- What is the price range at Buddy's Pizza near Birmingham: Open?
- Are there gluten-free options at New York Pizza Pie Birmingham?
- Is Brooklyn Pizza and Bar family-friendly in Birmingham: Open?
- Which pizza places near Birmingham: Open have outdoor seating?
I've been here · Write a review
The conversation · Be the first to share an opinion
