Noemic

Plymouth: Fine Dining, MI

What is the best italian restaurant in Plymouth: Fine Dining?

Updated October 16, 2026How we rank

The answer

The best Italian restaurants for fine dining in Plymouth, MI are La Bistecca Italian Grille, Cantoro's Italian Market, and NICO & VALI Italian Eatery. La Bistecca is the highest rated with a 4.8 rating and praised for outstanding food, excellent service, and great wine selection. Cantoro's Italian Market is the most reviewed with 6194 reviews and noted for its excellent selection of fine food and deli offerings. NICO & VALI is recognized for excellent food and is highly regarded as the best Italian food in Plymouth by some reviewers.

Written by AI from the sources below; may contain mistakes.

Ranked · how we rank

  1. 1

    Cantoro's Italian Market - Plymouth

    4.7 ★ (6,194)in Plymouth

    Most reviewed4.7 from 6,194 Google reviews, 2.5 mi away

    • WhyExcellent selection of fine food and wine at Cantoro's Italian Market

    Own this business? Claim it

  2. 2

    NICO & VALI Italian Eatery

    4.5 ★ (1,327)in Plymouth

    Open now4.5 from 1,327 Google reviews, 0.2 mi away

    • WhyKnown locally as the best Italian food in Plymouth

    “The best Italian food in Plymouth, hands down!” — Google review

    Own this business? Claim it

  3. 3

    La Bistecca Italian Grille

    4.8 ★ (797)in Plymouth

    Highest rated, weighted by review volume4.8 from 797 Google reviews, 1.9 mi away

    • WhyFeatures amazing food and great wine selection consistently

    Own this business? Claim it

  4. 4

    Pizza e Vino

    4.7 ★ (943)in Plymouth

    Closest0.1 mi away, 4.7 from 943 Google reviews

    • WhyCozy chic restaurant with friendly service

    Own this business? Claim it

  5. 5

    Compari's On the Park

    4.3 ★ (1,656)in Plymouth

    Open now4.3 from 1,656 Google reviews, 0.1 mi away

    • WhyFast and friendly service in a great location

    Own this business? Claim it

Map

Sources · updated October 16, 2026

Ask a follow-up

Next: Italian restaurant open late in Plymouth: Fine Dining

Answered from the places on this page.

I've been here · Write a review

The conversation · Be the first to share an opinion