Noemic

Plymouth, MI

What is the best italian in Plymouth?

Updated October 2, 2026How we rank

The answer

Top picks in Plymouth: NICO & VALI Italian Eatery (4.5★, 1,321 reviews), La Bistecca Italian Grille (4.8★, 795 reviews), Cantoro's Italian Market (4.7★, 6,185 reviews).

Built from the sources below.

Ranked · how we rank

  1. 1

    NICO & VALI Italian Eatery

    4.5 ★ (1,321)$$0.2 mi from downtown Plymouth

    Italian

    Worth a competing quote4.5 from 1,321 Google reviews, 0.2 mi away

    • Why4.5★ from 1,321 reviews · 0.2 mi

    “The best Italian food in Plymouth, hands down!” — Google review

    Own this business? Claim it

  2. 2

    La Bistecca Italian Grille

    4.8 ★ (795)$$$2.0 mi from downtown Plymouth

    Italian

    Highest rated, weighted by review volume4.8 from 795 Google reviews, 2.0 mi away

    • Why4.8★ from 795 reviews · 2.0 mi

    Own this business? Claim it

  3. 3

    Cantoro's Italian Market

    4.7 ★ (6,185)$$2.5 mi from downtown Plymouth

    Italian

    Most reviewed4.7 from 6,185 Google reviews, 2.5 mi away

    • Why4.7★ from 6,185 reviews · open till 8 PM · 2.5 mi

    Own this business? Claim it

  4. 4

    Cantoro market

    4.7 ★ (820)$$2.5 mi from downtown Plymouth

    Italian

    Worth a competing quote4.7 from 820 Google reviews, 2.5 mi away

    • Why4.7★ from 820 reviews · open till in 33 min · 2.5 mi

    Own this business? Claim it

  5. 5

    Compari's On the Park

    4.3 ★ (1,652)$$0.1 mi from downtown Plymouth

    Italian

    Closest to you0.1 mi away, 4.3 from 1,652 Google reviews

    • Why4.3★ from 1,652 reviews · open till 9 PM · 0.1 mi

    Own this business? Claim it

Map

Sources · updated October 2, 2026

Ask a follow-up

Answered from the places on this page.

I've been here · Write a review

The conversation · Be the first to share an opinion