Noemic
New American

Old City Hall

4.5 ★ · 1,340 reviews on Google · $$$

Closed now · 814 Saginaw St, Bay City, MI 48708

Old City Hall occupies a circa-1890s former city hall building at 814 Saginaw St in Bay City, MI. The casual gourmet restaurant combines a historic, cozy setting with upscale touches, placing it among the city’s date-night dining options. It serves brunch, lunch and dinner, with offerings that include comfort food, small plates, and vegan, vegetarian and healthy options. An on-site bar serves tap beer, wine and cocktails, and happy-hour food and drinks are available. Beyond dinner for two, Old City Hall accommodates groups and offers a private dining room. Live music is among its listed features, along with desserts and coffee. Reservations are accepted and recommended for dinner. Practical amenities include free street and lot parking, wheelchair-accessible entry, seating and restrooms, and Wi-Fi. A children’s menu and high chairs are available, and dogs are allowed outside. Guests can dine in with table service or order takeout or delivery.

Old City Hall

Know before you go

  • Circa-1890s former city hall setting
  • Tap beer, wine and cocktails
  • Live music
  • Vegan and vegetarian options
  • Private dining room
  • Reviewers often praise the food (3 mentions)
  • Reviewers often praise the service (2 mentions)
  • Reviewers often praise the quality (1 mentions)

From 3 recent reviews

Reviews

No Noemic member reviews yet.

Excerpts from public reviews

  • We really enjoyed our experience dining here. The fresh bread is delicious, and we loved the Shrimp Cremosi appetizer! Perfectly thinly breaded with an amazing sauce! Every entree we order was goo… — Google, 5★, September 30, 2026
  • What a great place to meet friends! Fantastic food served by super friendly people. — Google, 5★, September 19, 2026
  • Highly recommend, great food, attentive entertaining staff — Google, 5★, September 17, 2026

Questions and answers