Noemic
Pizza

Old World Pizzeria

4.6 ★ · 301 reviews on Google · $

Closed now · 116 N Michigan Ave, Saginaw, MI 48602

CallDirectionsWebsite

Old World Pizzeria at 116 N Michigan Ave in Saginaw, MI serves New York-style pizza, with specialty slices and house-made hot honey among its offerings. The counter-service pizza place serves lunch, dinner and dessert, with seating for dining in and options for takeout and delivery, including no-contact delivery. Outdoor seating and catering are also available. Its Google rating is 4.6 out of 5 from 301 reviews. The atmosphere is described as casual and cozy, and the restaurant welcomes children, families and groups while also accommodating solo diners. It is listed as LGBTQ-friendly and a transgender safe space. Practical amenities include Wi-Fi, free street parking, and credit and debit card payments. The entrance, parking and seating are listed as wheelchair-accessible. For a quick bite or a sit-down meal in Saginaw, MI, its focus is pizza and comfort food, with service options for eating on site or at home.

Old World Pizzeria

Know before you go

  • New York-style pizza
  • Specialty slices
  • House-made hot honey
  • Casual counter-service dining
  • Takeout and no-contact delivery
  • Reviewers often praise the service (1 mentions)
  • Reviewers often praise the quality (1 mentions)
  • Some reviewers mention service (1)
  • Some reviewers mention food (1)
  • Some reviewers mention wait (1)

From 2 recent reviews

Reviews

No Noemic member reviews yet.

Excerpts from public reviews

  • Fantastic pizza and service. 10/10 recommend 👌 — Google, 5★, September 25, 2026
  • If it were made fresh I believe it would be one of the best I've had. Only have been here once. Ordered ahead of time online to pick up at 6pm. When I walked in at 5:45 the owner I presume grab… — Google, 2★, September 22, 2026

Questions and answers